Starred review from April 1, 2023
A spin instructor who can't believe that her sister killed herself looks into the circumstances of her death and unearths a shocking series of secrets that go back to their childhood. Willa Stannard was a news anchor on KZTV in Chicago until a panic attack ended her career in the middle of a broadcast. When she's found in her bathtub, her wrists slit and a cryptic note to her sister nearby, all the evidence points to suicide. But Sawyer Stannard can't believe that the sister she'd grown away from years ago would end her own life. Despite a distinct lack of encouragement from Officer Mallory Curry, she fastens on a true-crime story Willa had pseudonymously immersed herself in for TruthShout, a local newspaper: the kidnapping 26 years ago of 18-month-old Melody Wynne from her parents' home in rural Michigan. Corbin Campbell, the Trowbridge County deputy who took the lead on the case, never found enough evidence to arrest either Abel Bowen, a neighbor of the Wynnes' with a criminal past, or self-anointed psychic Merrill Vaughn, who inserted himself into the investigation repeatedly until he died. Why was Willa so obsessed with the ancient case that she not only covered it for TruthShout, but prepared a book-length manuscript, Cry of the Cicadas: The True Story of Melody Wynne's Disappearance, for literary agent Gemma Matthews? And why does Gemma, who's supported the project enthusiastically, suddenly have cold feet about submitting it for publication without more solid evidence supporting its conclusions? Producing that evidence will exact a fearsome cost on Sawyer, with anxious readers half a step behind her. A welcome debut that's both a fleet thriller and a pathology of sisterhood at its most harrowing.
COPYRIGHT(2023) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.