My Big Fat Fake Marriage

January 1, 2025

Stein (When Grumpy Met Sunshine) employs the fake-marriage trope in this rom-com featuring Henry Samuel Beckett, a sweet and sunshiny editor who has always been single, and Connie Evans, an aspiring writer who somehow finds herself pretending to be his wife at a writing retreat. With a 75K-copy first printing. Prepub Alert.

Copyright 2024 Library Journal

Copyright 2024 Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.

Starred review from March 1, 2025
When two London neighbors decide to fake being husband and wife, they're not prepared for the true feelings that emerge in the process. Thirty-one-year-old Connie, an aspiring writer, has never trusted self-proclaimed "nice guys," because her track record when it comes to dating them has been terrible. Either their niceness is a facade meant to cover up some big lie--like a wife at home--or they're just pretending to be decent to get into her bed. That's why she scrutinizes everything her American neighbor, Henry Samuel Beckett, does for her; there's no way anyone this cheery, well dressed, and all-around kind isn't hiding some deep, dark secret. To an extent, Connie's instincts are correct, since Beck does have a secret, but when he finally reveals the truth, she realizes her early skepticism may have been unfounded. At 37, Beck has always been single, but he may have told a teeny-tiny white lie about being married to save face with an irritating colleague at the publishing house where he works. Then, when Connie and Beck run into each other at a book party, she somehow tells his annoying coworker that she's the mystery wife. Now, the two of them are trapped having to preserve this lie, especially since they're both heading to a writing retreat where all eyes will be on them--so they'll need to get their stories straight, not to mention figure out how to sleep in the same bed. Despite her earlier reservations about Beck, Connie finds herself in the best position to learn who he really is, and the truth is that he isn't just any nice guy--he's way better. Stein's latest is a sweet rom-com with the kind of endearing, cinnamon-roll hero the genre can always use more of, as well as a heroine who's willing to lower her walls and trust someone who might actually be worth the effort. While it would have been nice to see Connie and Beck's romantic dynamic develop further outside the retreat setting, the characters' strong introspection and emotional vulnerability make the book impossible to put down. A fake marriage leads to real feelings in this charming rom-com.

COPYRIGHT(2025) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.